HPV retardation?

Michelle Bachmann accused Rick Perry that he is causing woman to be "retarded"(because the HPV vaccine) those where her words. Just because he is doing something good to the community. A Bioethics named Art Caplan has challenged her with "The HPV challenge" which states that if she can produce a a case that she can prove her case verified by three medical experts. if she proves it the Bioethics will donate money to a charity of her choice. If she fails she will have to donate 10k to a charity he chooses. What do you guys think? Will she be able to prove it?